After determining that
was a Cultist, the village returned to their homes, relieved that they had not chosen incorrectly.
That evening, a terrible wind ripped across the town from the ocean, howling against the houses of Innsmouth. Rain lashed against the streets, forcing everyone to stay indoors, but, deep within the woods, an eldritch fire danced with green flames, illuminating a red-robed, hooded figure.
Hefting a knife, the Cultist raised their face to the sky and cried, "Oh great and powerful One! I know I have angered you in a past life. Now I must grovel before you to absolve my sins. The stars are not yet fully aligned for only then will your hunger be appeased!
"Until the time of Feasting has come...I must give you...an appetizer!"
The flames surged higher as if responding to the Cultist's voice and the figure backed away, stealing through the trees back to town.
Creeping through the shadows, the Cultist's eyes fell on their victim's home, the lights inside off, the inhabitants asleep. Just as the Cultist's hand touched the door handle, a figure shot from around the corner of the house, their fist connecting with the Cultist's head.
"Not tonight you don't!" the Bodyguard shouted as the melee began.
The Cultist slashed and stabbed but it was no use, the Bodyguard's kung fu was simply stronger.
"All will be devoured!" the Cultist spat before dropping something on the ground, a bright flash of light and smoke blinding the Bodyguard. When the smoke cleared the Cultist was gone. Their job done, the Bodyguard dusted their hands off and went back to their own home to a night's rest well earned.
Meanwhile...across the town, a figure ran across the street, ducking, bobbing, and weaving between the houses, doing its best to remain unseen. It had just unlocked the back door of a house when a rough hand grabbed it by the shoulder and threw them to the ground. As the horrified person looked up, lightning flashed across the sky, illuminating their assailant who stood above them, a metal baseball bat held upraised.
"AHA! GOT YOU, YOU FOUL CULTIST!" the shadow cried, the bat connecting with the side of the shadow's head with a crunch, dropping her to the ground bonelessly.
"Never again will you threaten our fair hamlet! Never again will you...uh...er..." it was then that a stray lightning bolt flashed across the sky, illuminating the camera that had fallen and broken against the ground. "Crap."
The Vigilante fled into the night.
As the sun rose in the morning sky, the clouds parting as the rain abated, the village realized that one of their number was missing. Searching, they found the body, soaked from rain, eyes staring without seeing at the clouds above.
---The BODYGUARD saved.
celothae the PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR is dead!---
((Mod note: Night Round is from whenever Day Round ends until 12:30PM, at which point the next Day Round begins. Each Night Round I will make a fresh post for Specials to respond in so please do not go back and re-use the original post where I let you know that you were a special. Thanks!))
That evening, a terrible wind ripped across the town from the ocean, howling against the houses of Innsmouth. Rain lashed against the streets, forcing everyone to stay indoors, but, deep within the woods, an eldritch fire danced with green flames, illuminating a red-robed, hooded figure.
Hefting a knife, the Cultist raised their face to the sky and cried, "Oh great and powerful One! I know I have angered you in a past life. Now I must grovel before you to absolve my sins. The stars are not yet fully aligned for only then will your hunger be appeased!
"Until the time of Feasting has come...I must give you...an appetizer!"
The flames surged higher as if responding to the Cultist's voice and the figure backed away, stealing through the trees back to town.
Creeping through the shadows, the Cultist's eyes fell on their victim's home, the lights inside off, the inhabitants asleep. Just as the Cultist's hand touched the door handle, a figure shot from around the corner of the house, their fist connecting with the Cultist's head.
"Not tonight you don't!" the Bodyguard shouted as the melee began.
The Cultist slashed and stabbed but it was no use, the Bodyguard's kung fu was simply stronger.
"All will be devoured!" the Cultist spat before dropping something on the ground, a bright flash of light and smoke blinding the Bodyguard. When the smoke cleared the Cultist was gone. Their job done, the Bodyguard dusted their hands off and went back to their own home to a night's rest well earned.
Meanwhile...across the town, a figure ran across the street, ducking, bobbing, and weaving between the houses, doing its best to remain unseen. It had just unlocked the back door of a house when a rough hand grabbed it by the shoulder and threw them to the ground. As the horrified person looked up, lightning flashed across the sky, illuminating their assailant who stood above them, a metal baseball bat held upraised.
"AHA! GOT YOU, YOU FOUL CULTIST!" the shadow cried, the bat connecting with the side of the shadow's head with a crunch, dropping her to the ground bonelessly.
"Never again will you threaten our fair hamlet! Never again will you...uh...er..." it was then that a stray lightning bolt flashed across the sky, illuminating the camera that had fallen and broken against the ground. "Crap."
The Vigilante fled into the night.
As the sun rose in the morning sky, the clouds parting as the rain abated, the village realized that one of their number was missing. Searching, they found the body, soaked from rain, eyes staring without seeing at the clouds above.
---The BODYGUARD saved.
((Mod note: Night Round is from whenever Day Round ends until 12:30PM, at which point the next Day Round begins. Each Night Round I will make a fresh post for Specials to respond in so please do not go back and re-use the original post where I let you know that you were a special. Thanks!))

Comments
So the bodyguard protected the right person, and the vigilante killed the PI. Way to go vigilante. ugh.
Since there was only one cultist, and I don't think the cultist can try to sacrifice themselves, the bodyguard knows for sure who one of the villagers is.
Dumb luck? Or did both the bodyguard and the cultist pick a "good player" to protect/attack?
Anyone care to come forward? If we get two claims of bodyguardness, we just lynch them both and we win. Otherwise, it'd be good to have two confirmed villagers.
Theweaselking did some suspicious last minute vote shifting as well.
Stride was uncharacteristically quiet.
In the end though, I must
VOTE RAISHA
because they didn't post at all yesterday.
Jiminy. Guess it's all deductive reasoning now.
The last-minute vote-switching bothers me a bit, but on the other hand it nabbed us a cultist, so I'm not honestly too suspicious of it. With only two cultists, sacrificing one to provide the other some cover is a pretty risky plan.
Otherwise, who do we know who Celothae might have pissed off?
We've got 14 villagers remaining. The specials remaining are:
For the home team:
1 Doctor
1 Thrill-Killer
1 Vigilante
1 Bodyguard
For the bad guys:
1 Sorcerer
1 Cultist
IF all the good guy specials come out, we've got at least four and possibly five (if we know who the bodyguard saved and it weren't another special) confirmed villagers. 5/14 is one hell of a voting block. The vigilante will also know who not to kill at night. The doctor knows who to save. The bodyguard has some idea who to protect. If we get double claimants for any role, we just lynch them both.
I think we could actually wrap this up in short order.
"Never again will you threaten our fair hamlet! Never again will you...uh...er..." it was then that a stray lightning bolt flashed across the sky, illuminating the camera that had fallen and broken against the ground. "Crap."
[Golfclap]
Celothae wasn't a cultist,
I *know* I was picking at random,
a cultist voting first on the very first round would be very ballsy,
Stride voted *in retaliation* to Snoopy voting for him,
and that leaves Makellan.
I think I will VOTE MAKELLAN and do a repeat of yesterday's question: Mak, why should I not suspect you?
VOTE Raisha.
She hasn't bothered to play yet, and I don't see the point to having the GM kill her and another one of us.
Please have a spirited debate while I'm wandering off, I want to be able to figure out who to protect tonight.
I vote abstain for now, but will cast my lot against someone later given a good reason.
The cultist can take out the bodyguard now. Doctor, identify yourself and you and the bodyguard can protect each other at least one more night.
Snoopy is essentially proven not a cultist by not dying last night.
On the game-extension matter: I dislike it because I'd like to see just one game end quickly, with a minimum of villager deaths. We'll play again! Let's save this town first! Who's voting for giving the sorcerer more power? That sounds like a cultist thing to do to me.
VOTE RAISHA
I'm currently suspicious of both people who advocate any further special knowledge.
I came out, well, cause I'm dumb and cause I see that the village only loses if I get killed. So I took the calculated risk that knowing I am the bodyguard will help you all not lynch me on accident. But now I'm a giant target, I see no reason for the doctor to be so as well.
The Doctor could protect me tonight AND not put themselves in danger by staying silent.
Why would you want them to do otherwise?
Raisha thought we were starting on the 15, so she's a bit behind.
All she needs to do to avoid commiting suicide is posting once, although the lynching...
All this debate over method is kind of futile and doesn't help us get to the real problem. And that is we still can't go fishing because there is a cultist amoung us! Who seems the most suspicious?
Well, crap. This ruins all my math from before.
Someone who doesn't seem concerned about votes against them is more likely to be a crazed cultist.
chaos_dancer - CULTIST
celothae - PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR
THE LIVING
chelleann77 - claims bodyguard, uncontested
theweaselking - claims vigilante, uncontested
snoopyh42a - saved by bodyguard on night 1
zhymmy - no posts on day 2
maggiebloome - no posts on day 2
gorillashaman
starryshadows
stride
reyl
urbanwolfie
raisha
makellan
sylvan
flowen
roles still unknown/unclaimed:
cultist, sorcerer, doctor, thrill-killer
SEE? Now. *points a finger at
(Also, I've been sick the last 24 hours and haven't had a chance to dive into the comments on this thread, sorry guys)
vote makellan
oh, look. I'm dead. Silly me for going out to dinner last night rather than posting more.
Ok, so since I'm not a special (though claiming one is pretty tempting right now), I can only say that a cultist would have, upon discovering that the votes were going against him, professed to be a useful special, or even contested an existing special while making a good argument about hiding from the cultist. A cultist would sew confusion and discontent among the village.
On my tombstone, I'll have it read "Just a Villager, like he said!"
Thank you all for your time.
GS: people find your logic suspicious mostly because you're just as good at it no matter which side you're on in a specific game. Poking holes in it requires sufficient understanding, which I find difficult this time because you're likely right, while voting against you only requires a rallying cry and a pitchfork. Good luck!
I am the THRILL KILLER.
Sorry, Maggie. Random choice says you go today.